The Music Observer 10: Looking back at 2023 [Albums]

Here's the Music Observer round up of standout albums of the year gone by. As you can see from the length of this post, it’s been hard to keep up with the albums this year; we've witnessed another wonderful flood of great musical art. It's really encouraging to see that this art-form is anything but dead, and in fact is thriving and growing! (My top picks of this year's singles can be found here and EPs are coming soon.)

THE MUSIC OBSERVER 10: ALBUMS

As I've said before, for me a good album must work as an end-to-end product. It must be something curated with thought and care, with a coherent theme, story or arc. These are the 10 albums which met that brief for me, more than any others I’ve listened to, during 2023. As with previous years, I've also included a lot of "Honourable mentions". (Note: These are not ranked, but are in alphabetical order by artist name.)

Coach Party - Killjoy  

I put this album straight on my shortlist as soon as I heard it in September. The album as a whole is a full on, fuzz-fuelled, dream rock anthem, with many of the individual tracks functioning like microcosms of that larger world. 


What an opening, too: four firmly-hit snare beats count us in for what turns out to be a fast-paced ride, as 'What's the Point in Life' makes it clear that Coach Party aren't going to be wasting any time. It's about short album, 10 tracks taking up less than half an hour end to end; only two tracks are more than three minutes long. But it doesn't feel rushed or dashed off. The album does its job very, very well, mixing some rapid-fire rants with fractionally slowed down songs (which feel almost epic in this context). 'Hi Baby' is one of the shorter ones, and also one of the most catchy and memorable. 

'Born Leader' is a stand-out track: it draws you in with a promise right from the start, and doesn't disappoint; the guitar riffs here echo with a muffled wail while the drums beat at just the right level, and vocals from Jess Eastwood veer from strident to sultry.

I'm still itching to see Coach Party live; it just hasn't quite worked out yet. Hopefully 2024 will be the year it finally does.

[Listen here.]

FIZZ - The Secret To Life  

This band are perhaps the best gift 2023 has given us. They're a genius collaboration; the super group we probably didn’t realised we desperately needed, but who it would seem hard to live without now. 

Their debut album is a record full of unique and often unexpected touches - tiny, carefully-wrapped gifts - and one of those albums where you hear something new every time you listen. 

Each individual contributes their own stylistic touches, such as their subtly different but similarly winning vocal styles, but there's never a feeling of anyone wanting to steal - or even borrow - the spotlight. This selflessness brings a strong feeling of easy camaraderie to all of FIZZ's performances, and this is reflected all the way through the album. There’s room for everyone at a FIZZ party. 

[Listen here, and read my live review for LeftLion here.]

Hannah Grae - Hell Is A Teenage Girl  

This record could be described as an EP (and is in some places), but I'm classing it as an album - it's only nine tracks, and 25 minutes long, but, hey, that fits with the apparent trend and besides it feels like an album to me, so that's where I'm putting it. And it begins with an “overture”, too.

Many of the songs here are caustic, wry, barbed observations on growing up in this world, from a female perspective. Hannah, like the Welsh answer to Olivia Rodrigo, deals with toxic friendship, bullying, sexism and anxiety, as well as those worn-out clichés which are so often handed out regardless of the truth ("Welcome to the best days of your life" she snarls as 'Time of Your Life' opens). 

One of the best tracks on the album is 'I Missed The Joke' - see my top 10 singles for more on that one. Elsewhere, 

[Listen here, and read my thoughts on 'I Missed The Joke' here.]

Holly Humberstone - Paint My Bedroom Black  

My first impression of the debut album from Holly Humberstone was that it's more direct, more mature, and more determinedly poppy in many places, than her previous releases. There's a feeling that Holly is now freer and more confident to play with different vibes and rhythms: in places things are dark, soft and cinematic, but in others Holly has found the confidence to simply lay out her message in the form of a straightforward alt-pop ballad. 

'Paint My Bedroom Black' is a great choice to open the album, and from there, Holly seems to soar. 'Into My Room' became a radio favourite, with its catchy start which melds into bouncing but progressive rhythm. After that, Holly makes creative use of light and dark tones, slower and more pacey tracks. 'Ghost Me', 'Lauren' and 'Elvis Impersonators' are all great songs in their own right, all featuring clever lyrical references, relatable emotional outpourings. 

Above all, this record exudes integrity and honesty, and establishes Holly as a very credible alt-pop voice.
[Listen here, read my previous full album write-up here, and my live review for LeftLion here.]

Lanterns On The Lake - Versions Of Us  

A nine-song offering (is this, like, a thing now?), which does feel a bit brief, but I'm not going to complain: this has clearly been worked on with love and care. Tracks such as 'Rich Girls' sound crisp and straightforward, both musically and lyrically; while, others such as 'String Theory' are suitably expansive and cerebral. 'Thumb Of War' sounds sparse at first, but then breaks like a huge wave, almost overwhelming, before the wave recedes and the tide ebbs again. And there's room even on this short album for a near-epic final track: 'Last Transmission' is emotive and moving, using tried and tested chord progressions to great effect.

The whole of this record is a swirling, immersive experience, in the best LOTL tradition. It may not mark a particularly progressive stage compared with their last album, but it's a great listen and perhaps the relatively short running time makes it all the more accessible.

[Listen here. Read my previous thoughts on the band here.]

Lastlings - Perfect World

2023 was the year I discovered this Australian duo, and I fell in love quickly with their easy style; the release of their new album cemented that feeling.

This is another real experience of an album; sometimes veering into areas so chilled and vibey that they seem to take over your mind, rather than fading into the background.

Track 1, ‘Holding Me Like Water’, is a statement of intent, starting with chilly floating vocals and ambient sounds before crisp breakbeats join. It builds with care, enveloping you in subtly expanding sounds, falling away slightly at times before easing upwards again towards a soft peak — and we see the rest of the album lying spread out before us.

From there we visit lands of plenty, rich with warm synths and all-encompassing beats, with those clear, engaging vocals always hovering over it all. Look out for ‘Better Of Without You’, where the music reaches spikier peaks, and ‘Out Of My ahead’ which is lush and warm, a tropical interlude.

'Perfect World' is a record which feels entirely coherent; it makes sense and you won’t regret your visit.

[Listen here.]

The Murder Capital - Gigi’s Recovery  

Stunning, impactful, brooding and dark; often challenging, but also loads of fun. This record is all of that and more.

It features one of the best and most dramatic individual tracks of the year, ‘The Stars Will Leave Their Stage’. But the path to that track is laid beautifully: beginning with the first strange resonant sounds of ‘Existence’ which are overlaid with uncomfortable vocals, then streaming subconsciously into ‘Crying’, with its shifty beats, siren-like guitars and moments of relief as chords resolve. 

Further tracks see the band exploring the limits of more structured songs, while keeping everything flooded in ominous gloaming light. That’s the genius of this record: allowing different shades of expression, experimenting with a theme, finding new and exciting rabbit holes to dive down, and pulling us along with irresistible force.

[Listen here.]


The National - Laugh Track  

This record seemed to catch a lot of people by surprise (me included), and was the second album The National released in 2023 (the first was not so well received). It opens with the fabulous 'Alphabet City', which wends around starkly beautiful and often gravelly territories, at times feeling like it could hardly get off the ground but ultimately providing the realisation that sometimes good things need to come gradually; almost an hour and 11 tracks later, it closes out with the somewhat epic 'Smoke Detector' (which the Guardian recently called "the wildest song" the band have ever made). This is a classic album in all the best senses of the word: a long-form work, where each individual (and enjoyable) song knows its place and does a distinct job.

Enriching the record further, we're also treated to collaborations from Bon Iver (track 3, 'Weird Goodbyes'), Phoebe Bridgers (track 6, 'Laugh Track), and Rosanne Cash (track 11, ‘Crumble’).

One of my favourites on the album is ‘Turn off the House’. This is a dream of a track, one of those which just presses on and on, becoming everywhere and everything as you listen — somehow transforming into a part of your consciousness. A lot of the tracks on this album are like that, in fact, particularly throughout the central section of the record. This gives ‘Laugh Track’ its own clear and distinct feel, which soaks through it all, including those collabs. There are variations on the theme (such as ‘Space Invader’ which ramps up the energy and veers in a clamorous  direction before surrendering to the beautiful and strangely soothing ‘Hornets’), but those variations never depart too far from the core. 

[Listen here.]

Olivia Rodrigo - GUTS  

The first lines of 'all-american bitch' represent one of the best album openings of 2023. And the rest of this song, too, takes us quickly into Olivia Rodrigo's world. "Come here and let me teach you a thing or two," she seems to say to the listener, no matter who you are. It's a searing exposition of the unrealistic expectations repeatedly placed on women, and a brilliant way to start Olivia's second album which is in many ways a coming of age record, as well one packed with teen-pop/rock anthems. 

'GUTS' tells tales of love, friendship, enemies, and a rollercoaster of emotions. It's an enjoyable listen at one level, and - behind the polished production (which is absolutely fantastic) -  a challenging one at another. It's an album everyone should listen to, with an important message for us all. 

[Listen here, and read more of my thoughts on this album here.]

RAYE - My 21st Century Blues  This LP is vast and rich, covering, in 15 tracks, acres of territory and all the essential topics of these confusing times. RAYE beautifully balances epic sounds and confident, assertive declarations with delightfully self-effacing and honest moments. And there’s loads going on in each track and in the album as a whole.

The record, RAYE's debut album, opens with an atmospheric live introduction at the "world famous 21st century blues club", before (now into track two, 'Oscar Winning Tears') the star of the show clears her throat and begins, almost shyly (but don't be fooled), "Hello, it's RAYE here. Please get nice and comfortable and lock your phones, because the story is about to begin."

And it is a story: of RAYE's defiance in the face of a still-unrelentingly patriarchal, sadistic, juggernaut music industry; her own mistakes; and the lesson's she's learned. 

'Oscar Winning Tears' is a winning combination of spoken word blending into rap, opening into full-on soul, RAYE's voice reaching pleasing heights very early on. From there, it's a natural progression into 'Hard Out Here', more hip-hop but with big strings, and then the dance-y yet dark 'Black Mascara' - which has an awesome sense of continually rising nervous energy. This is only track four, but we've already covered a lot of ground. That mix-up of genres, influences and messages is reflected throughout the rest of the album. 

'Black Mascara' ends with a quick descent, becoming suddenly frowny and subdued; this lays the groundwork for the brutally honest  'Escapism'. Now, I know this track has been chronically overplayed on the radio this year, in this original version and re-mixed. But it's great to hear it in its full context. Almost three minutes in, the song takes a shift and becomes even more introspective, as RAYE mutters existentially, "I'll be naked when I leave and I was naked when I came ..." Then there's a reprise of the chorus where RAYE adlibs and plays with the melody before a brilliant section which layers on the effects and turns her voice into part of the instrumentation which supports her final spoken bars to a neat conclusion. 

After this, RAYE begins to show even more influences. There are a couple of strongly soul- and R&B-focused songs, (a standout) the stripped-back but very powerful 'Ice Cream Man', (a standout), an eco-conscious, quirky song backed by liquid DnB beats ('Environmental Anxiety'), a track featuring Mahalia ...

Some have described this record as lacking a clear theme - I disagree. The album reflects RAYE's eclecticism; it feels like what it is: someone pouring out their feelings, releasing pent-up creativity, desperate and passionate to share everything that's going on in their head. 

[Listen here.]

HONOURABLE MENTIONS

There are lots this year. I probably should do a top 20, but I’m stubbornly sticking to the format hence the long list below! These are all absolutely worth checking out, too.

Art School Girlfriend - Soft Landing  Softly engaging for the most part, with lots of chilled beats and muffled synth lines. But also, some low key bangers - take the first track 'A Place To Lie' for starters. This is a widely-encompassing listen, and very satisfying for many moods. [Listen here.]

Baby Queen - Quarter Life Crisis (Deluxe)  A well balanced record, sometimes presenting deceptively sugary pop, but always with a tongue-in-cheek, self-exposing approach; just a great listen, too. [Listen here.]

Billie Marten - Drop Cherries  An extensive collection of direct, confident modern folk songs, imbued with a hazy summer essence, but always pointing towards the future. Look out for ‘I Can’t Get My Head Around You’. [Listen here.]

Boygenius - the record  The genius (yep) and genuine affection and friendship of the three women who make up this super group really shines through. There’s warmth and closeness even as the trio speak out with unabashed ferocity, and a sense of humour, against this tedious male-dominated world, and as they celebrate life’s good things, too. [Listen here.]

Eleri - The Carnival  A joyous and upbeat album, blending pop, country and element of modern folk, and adding her own unique strain and chiming vocals. Eleri sounds energised and confident, happy to be sharing her work with us and always ready to entertain. [Listen here.]

Grian Chatten - Chaos For The Fly  A sense of poetic freedom and true self expression. This album only narrowly missed out on my top 10. [Listen here.]

JJ Lovegrove - The Lines We Leave Behind  Here’s the microreview I wrote for LeftLion earlier this year: Judi’s voice emerges like a flickering flame from the misty ambience of opening track, ‘Run’, before the album grows in power and intensity. In the centre, ‘The Call’ has a lo-fi feel but high impact, leading into the 80s-drenched ‘Dark Room’, with infectious pounding drums. After a long power down, we finish with the meandering ‘Power Cut’ and the slow-burning, moving, ‘End Credits’. The dawn to dusk concept is well executed, the tracks cross-fading, real-world samples adding a sense of immediacy, and the protagonist herself always present, but never intrusive. An impactful and memorable listen: a well-balanced and poetic work from an artist in a place of confidence. [Listen here.]


Josienne Clarke - Onliness  Crystalline. Essential. Entirely immersive. [Listen here.]

Miss Grit - Follow the Cyborg  Utterly of the future. While some moments may fall a little short, the album includes some stunning sounds, such as the thrummy, relentless electro-dance title track, and the jittery pulse of ‘Like You’. [Listen here.]   

Metric - Formentera II  Metric's track 'Doomscroller' was my "Epic banger of the year" in 2022; this year, part two of their album sequence takes the character of that song and teases it out into an entire worldscape. [Listen here, and read my previous thoughts on 'Doomscroller' here.]

Odd Beholder - Feel Better  Telling straightforward but important tales through the medium of an electric dreamscape. Highlights for me are ‘Woolen Sweater’, ‘Dirty Secrets’ and ‘Just Because I Regret It’. [Listen here.] 

Soda Blonde - Dream Big  Expansive, flowing and varied; the band take things to the next level here, covering lots of ground and providing a base for each member to show off their talents. A sense of crispness, urgency and passion. [Listen here and read my live review for the Songbird here.] 

Thea Gilmore - Thea Gilmore  Deftly delivered, powerfully feminist. The album opens very strongly with ‘Nice Normal Woman’ and just gets better and better as it unfolds. ‘Bones’ thrums along and unrolls like some sort of space highway, and you’re transported … ‘Hope and Fury’ and ‘Unravel Me’ are both robust and totally engaging, with subtle tweaks throughout; ‘Talking Out Of Tune’ is satisfyingly dramatic. Thea’s is an authoritative voice in the conversation here and this album is important as well as a really good listen. [Listen here.]

Tove Lo - Dirt Femme (Extended Cut) / Dirt Femme (Stripped)  Tove has treated us to two new variations on her brilliant 2022 album this year. I previously wrote about her ability to create interesting and innovative structures and play with varied ideas and themes; well, the “Stripped” version of ‘Dirt Femme’ shines a whole new light on her songs, revealing her talent for great songwriting - and a perfected voice - even further, and proving (if it’s needed) that Tove is more than “pop” or any other label she’s been given. The stark version of ‘Grapefruit’, just a piano and Tove’s intimate vocal, is sublime; and ‘How Long’ is interpreted with genius. She has not only made it work, but created a whole new beautiful song. I only wish that more than seven tracks had been given this treatment. The “Extended Cut” of the album at least scratches the itch for more Tove with extended versions of four of the album tracks. [Listen here and here and read my thoughts on last year’s album here.]

Slow Readers Club - Knowledge Freedom Power  A sustained wave of electro-synth-infused, upbeat euphoric energy, with a beautiful balance of darker tones. [Listen here and read my review for the Songbird here.]